Local’s Recommendations: A Taste of Myrtle Beach at Sea Captain’s House
- July 29, 2025
- Chloe Ketterer
When it comes to Myrtle Beach dining, locals know best, and they keep coming back to Sea Captain’s House for a reason. Nestled right on the oceanfront, our historic cottage-turned-restaurant has been serving generations of families, travelers, and locals who know where to find the best flavors on the coast. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a long-time guest, we’ve rounded up the dishes and drinks that our regulars rave about most. From timeless appetizers to indulgent desserts and refreshing cocktails, here’s your guide to the can’t-miss favorites that truly capture the spirit of the Carolina coast.
Appetizers That Set the Tone
There’s no better way to start your Sea Captain’s House experience than with a bowl of our She Crab Soup. Rich, velvety, and packed with flavor, this award-winning soup is a house specialty and a rite of passage for any true Myrtle Beach foodie. It’s made fresh daily with lump crab, delicate spices, and a touch of sherry, just the way it’s been served for decades. Locals will tell you: if you haven’t had the She Crab Soup, you haven’t really dined at Sea Captain’s.
For something crispier but just as beloved, the Fried Oysters deliver that perfect balance of tender and crunchy. Hand-breaded and fried to a golden finish, these oysters are a guest favorite that capture the taste of the sea in every bite. They’re the kind of appetizer that disappears from the table quickly, so you might want to order an extra plate if you’re sharing.
Entrées That Steal the Show
Our entrées are all about celebrating coastal tradition with Southern charm and generous portions. The Seafood Platter is the ultimate go-to for seafood lovers. It brings together flounder, shrimp, and scallops, all prepared just the way you like: broiled or fried. It’s a full ocean bounty on one plate, and a staple for those who want to try it all.
Looking for something hearty and rooted in Lowcountry flavor? Our Shrimp & Grits features plump shrimp simmered in a savory cream sauce, served with a fried cheese grits cake. It’s Southern comfort food at its finest and a warm, satisfying choice that locals swear by.
If you want a balance between land and sea, the Land & Sea entrée is the perfect pick. It pairs a seasoned 8 oz. filet of beef with jump fried shrimp, creating a combination that satisfies every craving. And for something a little different, but often requested by those in the know, try the Pecan Crusted Grouper. The grouper is sauteed in a crispy pecan crust and topped with a citrus beurre blanc, delivering a nutty sweetness that complements the tender fish beautifully. It’s a hidden gem that our regulars love to recommend.
Desserts That Feel Like Home
At Sea Captain’s House, we believe every meal should end on a sweet note, and our dessert menu is full of comforting, homemade classics. The Hummingbird Cake is a true Southern treat with layers of moist spiced cake filled with pineapple, banana, and pecans, all topped with a rich cream cheese frosting. It’s indulgent, nostalgic, and perfect for the ending of a delicious meal.
For something a little lighter but just as satisfying, the Key Lime Pie is a top pick. Creamy, tart, and made perfectly for you, it’s served in a buttery graham cracker crust and topped with fresh whipped cream. It’s the kind of dessert that refreshes your palate while giving you that last taste of tropical sunshine.
Drinks That Keep the Vibe Going
What better way to enjoy oceanfront dining than with a refreshing cocktail in hand? The Carolina Tea is a local favorite for a reason. Made with Firefly Vodka, a splash of pink lemonade, and garnished with a lemon wedge, this drink is light, smooth, and just sweet enough. It’s the perfect choice for a laid-back lunch or sunset dinner by the waves.
For something with a fruity twist, the Peachberry Martini delivers a burst of flavor in every sip. Blended with Pinnacle Peach Vodka, Pinnacle Blueberry Vodka, Triple Sec, cranberry juice, and just a splash of Sprite, it’s bright, vibrant, and just the right amount of fun. Whether you’re celebrating or just relaxing, this cocktail brings the beachside vibe to your glass.
Come Taste What the Locals Love
At Sea Captain’s House, we’re proud to serve the dishes and drinks that keep our guests coming back again and again. These local favorites have stood the test of time, bringing together fresh ingredients, coastal flavor, and true Southern hospitality. Whether you’re joining us for the first time or stopping by for your weekly favorite, there’s always something special waiting at your table.
Come discover why locals call us their favorite place on the beach. Walk-in’s welcome!